• Art
  • Photo
  • Life
  • Pop Culture
  • Books
  • Subscribe
  • SHOP KIOSK
  • ART CLASSES

Out Now Issue #47

Out Now Issue #47

  • Art
  • Photo
  • Life
  • Pop Culture
  • Books
  • Subscribe
  • SHOP KIOSK
  • ART CLASSES
5 May 2022
Pop Culture / Opinion

Some Like It Not: What Happened When Kim Kardashian Wore Marilyn Monroe’s Dress?

KK may be able to squeeze into MM’s gown for the Met Gala, but the movie icon’s star wattage is impossible to simply borrow, argues Rosalind Jana

Marilyn Monroe sings "Happy Birthday" to President John F. Kennedy at Madison Square Garden, for his upcoming 45th birthday. Credit: PictureLux / The Hollywood Archive / Alamy Stock Photo
Marilyn Monroe sings “Happy Birthday” to President John F. Kennedy at Madison Square Garden, for his upcoming 45th birthday. Credit: PictureLux / The Hollywood Archive / Alamy Stock Photo

When Marilyn Monroe takes to the stage to sing Happy Birthday to President John F Kennedy in May 1962, she is all flutter and glitter. The opening joke is that she is late. The punchline is herself. After missing her first cue, an empty spotlight awaiting, she suddenly appears. Clutching her white fur tight around her shoulders, she wiggles across to the podium.“Ladies and gentlemen, the late Marilyn Monroe.” Three months later, after her death at the age of 36, the portentous tragic double meaning of the word will not be lost. She removes the fur and flicks the microphone; her skin-tight Jean Louis dress studded all over with winking rhinestones.

As she begins to sing, her voice a breathy parody of everything that is feminine and glamorous and suggestive of sex, she is mesmerising. “There was like a hush over the whole place when I came on to sing Happy Birthday,” she would go on to tell Life Magazine, in the last interview she ever gave. “Like if I had been wearing a slip, I would have thought it was showing or something.”

Kim Kardashian arrives on the red carpet for The Met Gala, 2022. Photo by John Angelillo/UPI. Credit:
Kim Kardashian arrives on the red carpet for The Met Gala, 2022. Photo by John Angelillo/UPI. Credit: UPI / Alamy Stock Photo

This week, 60 years later, that Jean Louis dress made another outing. When Kim Kardashian arrived on the Met Gala red carpet, the swirling rumours were confirmed. She was wearing the Marilyn dress. Not a replica. The real deal. Now owned by Ripley’s Believe it or Not Museum, who bought it at auction in 2016 for nearly $5m, for one night it was set free from its carefully controlled conditions to grace the body of another monstrously famous woman.

Kardashian, who dyed her hair blonde for the occasion, spoke at the top of the Met’s steps about the “challenge” of wearing it. “It was a role,” she said seriously to American television personality La La Anthony as she detailed the 16 pounds she had to lose to fit into the gown. “I was determined.”

Tweet this

“Kim Kardashian arrived on the Met Gala red carpet wearing the Marilyn dress. Not a replica. The real deal”

Much has been made of this comment, as well as Ripley’s decision to lend the piece to Kardashian in the first place (she wore it only for the red carpet, changing into a duplicate after the original had been paraded for the cameras). As ever, Kardashian achieved her aim. Days later, everyone is still talking about it.

Archivists, for the most part, hate the idea of a priceless piece of costume history being exposed to the unpredictabilities of body and atmosphere in exchange for a photo opportunity. There has been widespread outrage over Kardashian’s proud admission of a strict three-week crash diet to whittle herself to the dress’s proportions, although arguably she was just admitting to what so many of her peers silently do year-round to maintain their place in the public eye. Ardent fans of Monroe are furious at the idea of Kardashian seriously aligning herself with the icon of the silver screen.

 

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Kim Kardashian (@kimkardashian)

 

The most notable part of the sartorial stunt is just how dull Kardashian looks. There is an uncanny valley feel to the photos, the dress draped seamlessly over Kardashian’s sculpted figure. Monroe, too, epitomised a beauty ideal. But so much of her sexiness, her physical charisma, was located in the body beneath.

In photos and video footage from that evening in the late spring of 1962, the gown’s silhouette isn’t smooth. It’s full of texture. The rhinestones form a suggestive second skin, accentuating Monroe’s stomach, her breasts, the deep V of her back as she moves. It is a fantasy, but one that feels fully connected to flesh.

Tweet this

“The most notable part of the sartorial stunt is just how dull Kardashian looks”

What is the purpose of wearing a dress as famous as this? The straightforward answer is that Kardashian sees her role as that of a fellow American icon, the rightful inheritor to Monroe’s diamond tiara. It is the perfect coda to her 2021 Met Gala costume. Then, Kardashian appeared clad head to toe in black Balenciaga, the implication being that we didn’t need to see her face to recognise her.

This time she moved beyond herself, into the realm of celebrity cosplay. But the truth of her previous costume remains. Kim is so thoroughly recognisable by her body, which she has toned, enhanced, and skimmed into submission, that on her Marilyn’s gown becomes just another dress. Kardashian cannot access its power, in part because her physical form is a product and mirror of our modern moment.

Marilyn Monroe and Steve Smith (brother-in-law of President John F. Kennedy) during an evening reception in New York, 1962
Marilyn Monroe and Steve Smith (brother-in-law of President John F. Kennedy) during an evening reception in New York, 1962. Credit: American Photo Archive / Alamy Stock Photo

Monroe knew a thing or two about selling her own image. “It’s nice to be included in people’s fantasies but you also like to be accepted for your own sake,” she added in that famous last interview. “I don’t look at myself as a commodity, but I’m sure a lot of people have.” It is a prescient reflection given the ongoing re-evaluation of Monroe’s legacy ever since her death in August 1962.

Immortalised in Warhol’s room-sized screen prints, his technicolour doll has frequently been seen as more image than human, more tragic symbol than complex life, more dumb blonde than highly intelligent woman. Though still frequently mischaracterised, there has been greater room in recent years for acknowledgment of Monroe’s intellect, political sympathies, and deep unease at her own brilliant ability to embody a nation’s (and perhaps a world’s) desire.

Tweet this

“Monroe was, we might say, attuned to the cruel disjunction between the finished commodity and the hidden labour it conceals”

In her book Women in Dark Times (2014), British feminist scholar Jacqueline Rose writes with beautiful clarity about Monroe’s unrelenting quest for self-knowledge, as well as her genuine gift for performance. “It was her unique talent to play almost every part as if it were a mockery of itself,” Rose observes, characterising Monroe as sort of post-war sacrifice to optimism and consumerism. “The woman whose sexuality is meant to redeem the horrors of history.”

Importantly, Rose draws out the ambivalence at the heart of Monroe’s celebrity. “One of the reasons she hated Hollywood was its raw exploitation. She was, we might say, attuned to the cruel disjunction between the finished commodity and the hidden labour it conceals.”

Kim Kardashian arrives on the red carpet for The Met Gala, 2021. Photo by John Angelillo/UPI. Credit: UPI/Alamy Live News
Kim Kardashian arrives on the red carpet for The Met Gala, 2021. Photo by John Angelillo/UPI. Credit: UPI/Alamy Live News

Kardashian knows herself to be a commodity too. One whose public persona is also intimately tied to sex. But there is no ambivalence about this, and little playfulness. She might lay bare her hidden labour for all to see (her weight loss, her dedication to the dress) but this is immediately justified as necessary in service to her vision. It’s not just Kardashian’s body that is polished but her ambition too.

In her diaristic notes, which she made constantly throughout her career, Monroe once wrote, “Discipline‒Concentration. My body is my body every part of it.” In the lead up to the Met Gala, Ripley’s gifted Kardashian a lock of Monroe’s hair, perhaps as reward for her own discipline. Every part of Marilyn’s body is no longer entirely her own body.

“Oh my god,” Kardashian says in a video of her responding to the gift. “I’m literally going to do some crazy voodoo shit and channel her.” But the hair, like the dress, refused to yield its magic. There are some parts of Monroe that she got to keep for herself.

Rosalind Jana is a London-based writer on fashion, art, culture, and travel

 

Opinion

Elephant’s writers sound off on the art-world issues that matter

READ MORE

Liked this post? Share it on social!





MORE TO READ

Read Next:

Performance Anxiety: Will We Ever Meet the Real Julia Fox?

Pop Culture

Performance Anxiety: Will We Ever Meet the Real Julia Fox?

Actress, artist, dominatrix, celeb sensation… the New Yorker ticks all those boxes, but is it all just a giant work of art?
Read More
Julia Fox arrives at the Vanity Fair Oscar party during the 94th Academy Awards, March 2022. Photo: Danny Moloshok. Credit: REUTERS / Alamy Stock Photo
Life

Venice Biennale Diary #3: “Paintings Need Lovers as Frogs Need Kisses…”

Curator Eoin Dara gives his account of the 2022 Venice Biennale preview week in the third of five diaries from five different writers
Read More
Life

Venice Biennale Diary #5: “It’s the Emily in Paris of the Art World”

Elephant’s deputy editor Louise Benson gives her account of the 2022 Venice Biennale preview week
Read More
Teresa Solar, Tunnel Boring Machine (2022) at the Arsenale Central Exhibition. Photo by Louise Benson
Life

Venice Biennale Diary #1: “The DJ Is Shouting: ‘When We Say Sonia, You Say Boyce…’”

Curator and broadcaster Katy Hessel gives her account of the opening week of the 2022 Venice Biennale
Read More

Keep in the loop

Get our weekly newsletter straight to your inbox

HUNGRY FOR MORE?

All Editorials
Picture Gallery

Snap Happy: Elephant’s Biennale Photo Diary

Feature

The BALTIC Interviews: “I Started to Call it the ‘Internet of Stink’”

Diaries

Venice Biennale Diary #4: “You’re Always Bumping into Someone From a Past Life”

Cui Jie, Basildon, 2021. Courtesy Antenna Space, the artist and Focal Point Gallery
5 Minutes With

Cui Jie: “People Are Too Fussy About Details…”

Diaries

Venice Biennale Diary #2: “It’s a Form of Art Boot Camp”

Advice Column

How Do I Go About Selling My Art? Should I Even Want To?

News

Choose Life: Welcome to Elephant’s Spring Summer 2022 Magazine

Elephant Kiosk

Own an Exclusive Malwine Strauss Print

Contemporary Classics

Eye Candy: Why Isn’t the Green M&M Sexy Anymore?

5 Minutes With

Donna Huddleston: “The Art World Is Both a Blessing and a Curse”

Under the Influence

Gisela McDaniel: “Gauguin’s Paintings of Pacific Islanders Felt Like Theft to Me”

Need To Know

Five Ways to Help the People of Ukraine

Elephant Kiosk

Bring the Dusty Days of Summer Home with This Limited-Edition Print

National Emergency Management Agency (NZ). Civil Defence poster campaign, Ministry of Civil Defence, New Zealand, 1980s
Sunday Read

Are You a Survivor? This Book Might Have All the Answers…





Issue 47 - Spring/Summer 2022

Elephant’s Spring/Summer 2022 edition embraces life. Performance art icon Marina Abramović beams out from one of our two covers, while our alternative special cover showcases one-time student and teacher pairing Sin Wai Kin and Tai Shani in full wedding regalia.

£13.99

More info Buy Me

  • About Us
  • Write for Us
  • Stockists
  • Privacy Policy
Follow Us
We use cookies for all the usual reasons. Click Accept and this message will go away. Accept More Info
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT